5.12.10

Poll: 1928 comedies

Chaplin's The Circus

Harold Lloyd's Speedy


Buster Keaton's (Joseph M. Schenck) Steamboat Bill jr

Buster Keaton's (with Lawrence Weingarten) The Cameraman


King Vidor's (with Irving Tharlberg and Marion Davies) Show People

King Vidor's (with William Randolph Hearst & Marion Davies) The Pasty


All great films in there own rights, but which is your favourite amongst them?

6 comments:

Jump_Raven said...

I haven't seen Show People, but I think Steamboat Bill Jr. takes the cake for the facade of the house stunt. After that, The Cameraman and The Circus and so on.

Ana said...

my vote goes for Steamboat Bill jr.

Matthew Coniam said...

The Circus for me.

FelixInHollywood said...

Just put in my vote for "The Patsy".

VKMfan said...

Hi Zoe!!!

Hope ya are doing well on the other side of the globe...

My vote is for 'Speedy', since...my mom is a big fan of the movie! I have seen about 10 minutes of it, and 'bits and pieces' of the other ones noted, so I can't make an educated vote, honestly...so this ones for mum!!!

KIG in NZ!!!
VKMfanHuey

Zoe said...

Greetings!
haha nice.
Speedy is a great film.
everything over here is fab and sunny. hope everything in the states is brill :)
Keep it gingery, as u say :D
zoe